Performance Mobility, Part 3: Foot And Ankle

Stay the Course[Author’s Note: This is Part 3 in a five-part series on functional mobility self-assessment and restoration for runners. See Part 1 on hip mobility, Part 2 on trunk mobility, and Part 4 on knee mobility.]

At the beginning of this series, I introduced the concept of performance mobility. To reiterate, there are certain fundamental motions required for healthy, efficient running related to the hips, trunk (spine and chest), knees, and ankles. The purpose and utility of performance mobility is to provide runners a way to self-assess their motion and, if need be, improve and restore it. Through this self-assessment, runners can monitor and manage their own mobility, stretch only when (and what is) needed, and stay ahead of aches, pains, and injury.

After covering the hips and low back, it’s time to turn to where the rubber meets the road: the feet.

Ruth Croft - 2016 TNF EC 50 Mile

Ruth Croft during the 2016 The North Face Endurance Challenge 50 Mile Championships demonstrating healthy foot and ankle mechanics. Photo: Kirsten Kortebein

Elite Feet and the Demands of Mountain, Trail, and Ultrarunning

Two years ago I introduced a concept called ‘Elite Feet,’ which outlines the vital role that a neutral and powerful foot loading and push-off plays in efficient and powerful running. Boiled down to a single sentence: the whole foot must contact the ground, then, using primarily the medial arch, actively push off behind.

This concept is relatively simple on the consistently flat surfaces of road and track running. Trails? Mountains? Mud? An entirely different story. Terrain, elevation, and surface integrity drastically impact how we use our feet and foot mobility.

For heavy vertical and uneven surfaces, achieving neutral-footed ground contact can be a tall order. Steep and slanted rocks, roots, and debris often makes a neutral strike nearly impossible. On top of that, in order to enhance stability–and avoid a face plant–the body often creates compensatory stability by landing with extra supination. A hyper-lateral foot strike keeps the knee tracking in line with the hip at the expense of stressful foot and ankle loading.

Achilles-supination

A hyper-supinated landing and its effect on foot and ankle joint loading. Photo: Joe Uhan

Prolonged, steep descents and rugged terrain can thus pack a heavy one-two punch on the feet and ankles, potentially creating major range-of-motion impairments via super-stiff ankles.

In addition to steep and rocky terrain, untrustworthy surfaces–leaves, sand, mud, snow, and ice–also impair a strong, athletic foot push-off. Every trail runner out there has at one point had to revert to the ‘duck-waddle shuffle,’ a compensatory running style that avoids assertive foot strike and push-off to negotiate slick terrain. Although beneficial in the short-term, if this strategy is maintained, before long, a relaxed, athletic foot push-off is lost.

Joe.duck.waddle

The author demonstrating the ‘duck-waddle shuffle’ at a very muddy 2015 Bandera 100k. Photo: Meredith Stevens

Stiff Ankle, Stiff Everything: Consequences of Lost Ankle Mobility

A whole-foot landing and active foot-and-ankle extension is the foundation of a strong overall leg push-off. Strong feet make strong hips. Conversely, a weak foot–due to stiffness or poor footing–impairs the entire system. Consequences of impaired foot push-off include:

  • Foot, ankle, and calf pain
  • Knee pain and stiffness (due to increased knee-flexion loading)
  • Hip pain and stiffness (due to decreased hip extension)
  • Low-back pain

While bilateral foot stiffness is problematic, any one-sided foot and ankle push-off impairment can have serious consequences to the system, creating a stride imbalance that can cause any number of injuries, ranging from foot to back pain–usually on the opposite side of the stiff foot and ankle!

The Foot- and Ankle-Extension Metric

While most runners are familiar with and employ ankle dorsiflexion (flexing) mobility, this metric assesses foot and ankle plantar flexion (extension):

Kneeling Ankle - Side

Joe Uhan performs the the foot and ankle mobility test for performance mobility.

Details: Begin by kneeling on the floor. (If you have sensitive or stiff knees, be very careful assuming this position. Go slowly and gently!) Slowly sit back on your heels. To further sensitize the test, try:

  • Putting heels together (internally rotating the foot and lower leg)
  • Wearing running shoes

Goals:

  • Foot and ankle should be able to lie (mostly) flat on the ground
  • Equal, symmetrical motion (left versus right)

Common Deficits:

  • Overall range-of-motion deficit: failure to achieve full plantar flexion (foot, front of ankle, and shin all touching the floor).

Implications:

Stiff ankle plantar flexion is a key marker in how well one uses his or her foot in push-off. Stiff motion here means a deficiency in push-off, and is especially problematic if stiffness is one-sided. This is a red flag for a potential stride imbalance and future aches, pains, and injury.

Restorative Exercises for Ankle Plantar Flexion

Kneeling Sit-On-Heels

In this case, the restorative stretch is the same as the test: sitting on the heels.

To perform: kneel on the floor, putting feet and heels together. Slowly sit back onto the heels. Options include either holding this position for a prolonged stretch of 20 to 60 seconds, or oscillating the stretch by sitting down, then raising up off the heels.

Additionally:

  • For moderate stiffness, simply sitting on the heels is sufficient.
  • For severe stiffness, consider putting a small pillow or folded towel beneath the lower shins.
  • For more subtle stiffness and to increase the stretch, wear shoes.

Kneeling Heel Pushes 

This stretch more directly targets the posterior ankle joint by putting direct pressure on the talus, the ‘go-between’ bone of the ankle joint.

To perform: with shoes off, turn to one heel, put hand between ankle bone and heel, and push downward, toward the floor and the toes. Perform 10 to 20 consecutive on-and-off oscillations. If it is not too tender (but stiff), this push can become more aggressive.

Ankle Push - Side

Joe Uhan demonstrating Kneeling Heel Pushes for foot and ankle mobility.

Ankle Push - Top

A closer look at Kneeling Heel Pushes for ankle and foot mobility.

Even in the absence of a major deficit, these exercises are excellent restorative stretches that help maintain foot and ankle flexibility. Best of all, improved plantarflexion mobility will enhance dorsiflexion motion as well!

Keeping the ankles supple, active, and strong is the subtle-but-crucial aspect of healthy and strong running. Check in with yours now and especially as your running volume and vertical increases!

Call for Comments (from Meghan)

  • Do you pass Joe Uhan’s foot and ankle mobility test? If not, is there asymmetry between your left and right sides or do you have an overall loss of your range of motion?
  • We asked the same question in the first two articles of this series, and we’ll try it again here. What kind of flexibility training or stretching do you engage in, if any? Do you find that it helps you in specific ways? If so, can you describe them?
Joe Uhan

is a physical therapist, coach, and ultrarunner in Eugene, Oregon. He is a Minnesota native and has been a competitive runner for over 20 years. He has a Master's Degree in Kinesiology, a Doctorate in Physical Therapy, and is a USATF Level II Certified Coach. Joe ran his first ultra at Autumn Leaves 50 Mile in October 2010, was 4th place at the 2015 USATF 100K Trail Championships (and 3rd in 2012), second at the 2014 Waldo 100K, and finished M9 at the 2012 Western States 100. Joe owns and operates Uhan Performance Physiotherapy in Eugene, Oregon, and offers online coaching and running analysis at uhanperformance.com.

There are 6 comments

  1. Luke

    Sometimes that kneeling sit-on-heels will give me foot cramps where my toes involuntarily curl in and i have to manually unwind things. Is that associated with lack of mobility or something else?

    Also it was pointed out to me that there is a difference in how far I can roll my ankles from side to side while standing (pronation to supination or something like that) – and the less mobility is on the side I’m currently waging a battle with persistent IT band syndrome. Seems like there’s more we’d want to pay attention do than just flexion in 1D?

  2. John B

    “Every trail runner out there has at one point had to revert to the ‘duck-waddle shuffle,’ a compensatory running style that avoids assertive foot strike and push-off to negotiate slick terrain.”

    Wrong. I have never resorted to such a thing. Some of us are mountain goats. I grew up running barefoot over seaweed covered rocks and playing on rugged terrain and sandstone outcrops. I plunge down steep, technical descents twice as fast as my clubmates (bar one) and I’m nearly 70 years old. On slick stuff I merely land very lightly and dance across maintaining pace. We are not all the same. Some us even wear the right shoes for the going!

  3. Sniff

    I’ve a hot or burning sensation at the base of my ankle. When I pull up on my toes I get a twinge along my big toe. It seems to “warm up” and doesn’t ache as much when I’m running. When I do the plantar flexion I can barley put weight on it. Normally I can do this with no issues. Been trying to ice and massage. Ugh…

  4. John Utah

    I tried this and my ankle flexibility, apparently, is terrible. I’d say there was at least a 2 inch gap from the floor. I am pretty sure that my foot and ankle will ever be able to lie on the floor. DO you really think I should be working on this and trying to have them tough the floor? I have had some MTSS issues, but I’m pretty sure that has nothing to do with this stretch.

  5. Alex

    Great article as always, Joe. I tried and I’m almost to the floor – a little heel-sitting ought to do it.

    My question is, why not also address dorsiflexion of the foot in the article? Lousy mobility in this (the opposite) direction was the root cause that my PT diagnosed for my chronic gastroc/soleus woes, and diligent work on increasing that range of dorsiflexion seems to be helping me.

    1. Romanair

      I was wandering the same. I figure, especially in steep inclines dorsiflexion mobility might impact performance. Getting your heel on the ground during support and early push off phase can preserve your calf muscles and prevent an early pump. In this respect, it would be interesting to know, what the maximal ankle dorsiflexion range of motion is. With this knowledge the degree of inclination where forefoot running gets inevitable could be determined and wether or not working on dorsiflexion mobility might enhance your performance during long steep inclines.
      Additionally, it would be interesting if the optimal dorsiflexion mobility for uphill running would interfere with overall performance when it comes to optimal tendon stiffness and elastic energy return (subject to discussion in the first series).

      Cheers,
      Roman

Post Your Thoughts