How the Group Think Predictions Work
Back to the predictions. Below, we attempt to apply a hive-mentality approach to see how the men’s and women’s fields play out when the collective thoughts of over 800 participants are accumulated. In addition to showing how many picks the top runners received for each place, we ranked the runners by MVP-style voting (i.e., 8 points for first, 7 points for second, and so on). Both the men’s and women’s tables show all WS runners who accumulated 30 or more points. Read on to see how the masses predicted the outcome for the Big Dance this weekend as well as some iRunFar analysis of those predictions and commentary on the race.
The Just Rewards
2013 Western States 100 Men’s Field
Interesting Men’s Field Notes
- Timothy Olson, the defending champ and course record holder, is the odds-on favorite for this year’s race. Not only did he receive the most points, he also received the most individual votes for both first and second place. Of the 823 ballots cast that included votes for all eight men’s places, an amazing 792 included a vote for Olson – for rate of over 96%! He also didn’t receive a single vote to finish eighth.
- With last year’s runner up Ryan Sandes not running this year (sorry to the 33 of you who cast a vote for him), the second-highest returnee from the men’s side, Nick Clark, easily received the second-highest point total while also receiving the highest number of votes cast for both third and fourth places.
- Two newcomers (at least if we look at the past decade and a half!), Mike Morton and Rob Krar took third and fourth respectively in the overall tally. Both received a significant number of first place votes with 1997 champ Morton actually having the second highest total a ways behind Olson. Neither was the top vote getter for any individual place.
- There are clearly three favorites for the win this year, Olson, Clark, and Morton with Krar a distant fourth. The consensus is that Dylan Bowman and Hal Koerner are long shots with a chance, while another six guys – Dave Mackey, Ian Sharman, Karl Meltzer, Cameron Clayton, Jorge Maravilla, and Joe Uhan – have only a snowball’s chance in hell to win this weekend… fortunately, at least part of that scenario will be in order. [Realistically, that should also cover anyone who has even the faintest notion of winning this weekend.]
- In separate voting for the men’s master’s win, Mike Morton had a large gap over Dave Mackey, 385 to 226, with Karl Meltzer back in third with 142 votes. Andy Jones-Wilkins was a distant fourth with 25 picks. No other male received a significant number of votes. That’s inline with how those four shook out in the general voting.
- In a significant variation from recent years, the top foreign-residing male vote getter who is actually running the race is Argentina’s Gustavo Reyes in 23rd with 37 points.
- The number of men receiving 10 or more points (the previous cutoff to make the chart) only increased from 28 last year to 31 this year… which is amazing given that an additional 13,222 points (80% increase) were in play for the men this year! That said, 107 men received at least one vote this year up from 71 last year and the previous high of 78 in 2011.
- With 55 points, Rick Gates seems to have benefited from a case of mistaken identity. Folks, this ain’t Rickey Gates. Just two spots off the table with 19 points, Scott Wolfe may have similarly benefited from those who like the odds of, say, Mike Wolfe.
2013 Western States 100 Women’s Field
- Rory Bosio, the top returnee (second last year), is far and away the most dominant prediction for a win in the five-year history of this prediction contest. From the total points standpoint, Bosio received 64% more points than the next point getter, while the next-biggest gap in contest history was when Ellie Greenwood received 42.5% more points than Lizzy Hawker last year… and we all know how that turned out for Ellie! [Uh, if you don’t know how that turned out for Ellie, she won in a course record time of 16:47.]
- The only previous women’s champ in the field, Nikki Kimball, received the second-highest number of points by a slight margin over 100-mile rookie Emily Harrison. Kimball was the top vote getter for both a third- and fourth-place finish. Like the third-ranked runner on the men’s side, Mike Morton, Harrison received the second highest number of votes to win.
- In separate voting for the master’s win, Meghan Arbogast led Nikki Kimball, 436 to 301, despite Kimball being ranked higher in the open category. No other women racing received a significant number of votes.
- As on the men’s side, we’ve got to look a ways down the table to find the top foreign-residing women’s runner who’ll be running this year’s Western States – Nicola Glidersleeve of Canada in 21st.
- An incredible 71 of the 84 (84.5%) women’s entrants in this year’s race received at least one vote!
- Last year, 27 women received at least 10 points. That number jumped to 43 this year. That’s in line with the 78% (12,872 point) increase in the total number of points cast for the women from last year to this year.
Call for Comments
- So what do you all think about the group prediction?
- What interesting observations have you made about the data?
- How would you change your picks based on what you know now?
- Want to make any of your predictions public? If so, leave a comment!
- Any statisticians want to dive into this?